Strawberry Jalapeno Jelly 16 oz $9.00 Strawberry Jalapeno Jelly, our mildest peppered jelly, a bit like a Jolly Rancher.Refrigerate After Opening. Quantity: Add To Cart Added! Strawberry Jalapeno Jelly, our mildest peppered jelly, a bit like a Jolly Rancher.Refrigerate After Opening.